VA vs. Conventional Loan: Which Mortgage Is Right for You?

VA Loan vs Conventional — how do they compare?

If you’ve served in the armed forces, you may be eligible for a VA loan to help you purchase or refinance a home.

These loans are great for many veterans and active-duty servicemembers because they require no down payment† and have no limits on how much you can borrow, depending on how much VA benefit you have available.

However, if you qualify for a Conventional loan, that’s an option worth considering as well.

Some Conventional loans require as little as 3% down, and while that’s not as good a deal as 0% down, you may be able to use gift funds toward the down payment.

So you’d get to buy a home with no money out of pocket, and you’d have more flexibility in the types of properties you can buy.

That’s just the tip of the iceberg when comparing the trade-offs of these loan programs.

That’s why we’ve done a deep dive on how VA loans and Conventional loans stack up, so you can figure out the best option for your home-buying plans.

VA vs. Conventional loans head-to-head

Most often, eligible veterans will choose a VA loan. That’s because they don’t require a down payment†, typically offer lower rates than Conventional and have no monthly mortgage insurance (PMI) requirement.

But there are a few reasons you might choose Conventional over VA:

1. You have a 20% down payment and want to avoid the upfront VA funding fee.
2. You want to buy a vacation home or rental property.
3. The home doesn’t meet VA minimum property requirements.

But this isn’t the end of the story. There are many more variables to consider when choosing between Conventional and VA.

But first, it helps to have some context on each program and who qualifies.

What is a VA loan?

VA loans are backed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), and they’re available to veterans, active-duty servicemembers and reservists from all branches of the military, as well as eligible surviving spouses:

• Army
• Navy
• Air Force
• Marine Corps
• Coast Guard
• National Guard or Reserves
• National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)
• Public Health Service (USPHS)
• Cadets at the US Military, Air Force, or Coast Guard Academies
• Midshipmen at the US Naval Academy
• Veterans of all branches
• Surviving military spouses who have not remarried and whose significant other:
  • Died in service
  • Died from a service-related injury or disability
  • Has been declared a POW (prisoner of war) or MIA (missing In action) for at least 90 days

If you’re a veteran, you must have been honorably discharged and if you’re active-duty, your current service record must be in good standing.

Both veteran and active-duty borrowers must also meet length of service requirements.

Length of service requirements

‍

*Eligible if served fewer days but discharged due to service-connected disability

**No allowance for fewer service days if discharged due to service-connected disability

***Eligible with minimum days if discharged due to a government decision, reduction in force, or a hardship. Eligible with less than minimum days only if separated due to service-connected disability.

VA Entitlement

Eligible VA borrowers who have never used their VA benefit or have full entitlement available can buy homes with zero down payment.

Borrowers who currently have a VA loan but still have entitlement available may be able to buy another home with zero down, or they can use a second VA loan with a down payment.

Wondering if you have entitlement available? Check out our guide on how to find your VA certificate of eligibility.

VA loan entitlement doesn’t expire, so you may be able to buy multiple houses with a VA loan within your lifetime. However, if you don’t have entitlement available — whether that’s because you already have a VA loan or a past loan has not yet been repaid — you won’t be able to use the program until entitlement has been restored.

Learn more: How many times can you use a VA home loan?

What is a Conventional loan?

A Conventional mortgage is the most common type of home loan. Unlike VA loans, Conventional loans are not backed by the U.S. government. Instead, they’re regulated by the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Also unlike VA loans, Conventional loans are available to all qualified homebuyers, rather than just members of the military community.

Many people use “Conventional loans” and “conforming loans” interchangeably, but there’s an important distinction.

Definitions

Conventional loan: All non-government-backed loans

Conforming loans: Loans that “conform” to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guidelines

Unless otherwise stated, we’ll be referring to conforming loans in this article.

OK, now let’s see how VA vs Conventional loan requirements stack up

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, here’s a quick comparison of VA loans vs conventional loans.

‍

Credit score

The minimum credit score to qualify for a Conventional is 620. However, lenders can set their own guidelines and some may require higher scores.

The VA’s suggested minimum credit score is 580. But again, lenders can set their own credit score requirements, and some will set their VA loan minimums at 620 or higher.

But here’s the good news if you have a low score — the VA encourages lenders to give VA loans to creditworthy servicemembers, so they have the discretion to approve you even if your score is lower than 580.

Now, if you qualify for both a VA and Conventional loan and your credit score is below 680, here’s a tip. Lenders sometimes give higher interest rates to borrowers with scores of 679 and below.

VA loans tend to have some of the lowest rates in the market. So if you have a lower score, you may want to go with a VA mortgage instead of a Conventional loan to save on interest.

Your interest rate will depend on your credit score, down payment, where you live, and other factors, so it’s best to get quotes for both programs from several lenders so you can evaluate which is most cost-effective for you.

Down payment

VA borrowers who have full entitlement available can get a home loan with 0% down†. Those who have partial entitlement may qualify with 0% down depending on the amount of entitlement available, the purchase price of their home and loan limits in their area.

Don’t worry, you don’t need to make these calculations yourself. When you apply for a VA loan, your loan officer can pull up your certificate of eligibility (COE) within minutes to see how much entitlement you have available.

Conventional loan down payment requirements are now as low as 3%. In the past, you needed a 20% down payment to buy a home, so the new guidelines make it significantly easier to qualify for a loan.

Those who can come up with a 20% down payment easily might consider a Conventional loan, since there is no upfront funding fee. More on VA funding fees later.

Related reading: Conventional 97 Loan: How to Qualify for a Low Down Payment Mortgage

Using gifts for your down payment

If you have partial entitlement and need to make a down payment on a VA loan, the VA allows you to use gift funds (such as from friends and family) or down payment assistance†† toward that cost. And if you qualify for a 0% down VA loan, you can use gifts toward your closing costs, further reducing the upfront cash you need to buy your home.

A number of Conventional loan programs allow you to use gift funds toward your down payment as well. Fannie Mae HomeReady and Freddie Mac’s HomeOne® and Home Possible® programs let you use gifts to cover the entire down payment amount.

Some Conventional loan programs may require a minimum borrower contribution, meaning a certain percentage that must come from your own funds. But the three mentioned above, all of which are great options for first-time homebuyers, have no minimum contribution rules.

Debt-to-income ratio

Debt-to-income ratio (DTI) refers to your total monthly debt obligations — including your housing payment — as a percentage of your gross monthly income (meaning your income before taxes and deductions).

When it comes to DTI, the VA allows flexibility. A mortgage lender can approve a borrower with a higher DTI for a VA loan if they have compensating factors, such as a high credit score and steady income, to counterbalance it.

Conventional loan DTI is based on the automated underwriting response for your loan. But the lower you can get that number, the better. A lower DTI can increase your chances of qualifying for a Conventional financing and make you eligible for more competitive interest rates.

A low DTI signals less risk to lenders, since you’re less likely to have trouble making your monthly mortgage payment on top of your other debts.

Property types

Both VA loans and Conventional loans can be used for several property types, including:

• Single-family homes
• Multifamily properties up to four units
• Condos
• Townhouses
• Manufactured homes

A big difference between these mortgage loans is that VA loans cannot be used to buy a vacation home or investment property while Conventional loans can. The VA loan can only be used to buy a new primary residence.

Here’s a hack, though: buy a multifamily property with a VA loan and live in one of the units while you rent out the others. That satisfies the primary residence requirement while also giving you a chance to earn some extra income.

Property requirements 

The VA issues strict minimum property requirements (MPRs) for the homes it will back. The MPRs are meant to ensure that veterans and servicemembers are buying homes that are safe, structurally sound, and provide adequate living space, plumbing, and other critical amenities.

Before a lender can approve a VA loan, a VA-approved appraiser will need to look over the property to make sure it meets those MPRs and to assess the home’s value. If the appraiser flags any issues for repair, those fixes must be completed before the loan can close.

And if the appraisal comes in lower than the purchase price, you’ll need to negotiate with the seller. Lenders cannot issue VA loans for more than the home is worth.

Conventional loans also require appraisals, as lenders also need to ensure that they aren’t giving loans worth more than the home’s fair market value.

An appraiser for a Conventional loan assesses the safety and livability of the property, and the home must be assessed at a value equal to or greater than the loan amount for the loan to be able to close. But the requirements can be less exacting than those issued by the VA.

Learn more: VA Home Loan Property Requirements (MPRs): A to Z Guide

A note on VA property appraisals

Because of the MPRs and the VA appraisal rules, VA loans have gotten a reputation for being harder to close.

Some sellers prefer offers with Conventional loans because they assume the sale is more likely to go off without a hitch. They worry that accepting a VA offer means they’ll need to make costly repairs or settle for a lower sale price.

However, that’s not necessarily true. VA borrowers are qualified buyers, especially those who come to the table with underwritten preapprovals. As for the MPRs, the VA wants to ensure the home is in good, livable condition. If a property is well-maintained, with no hazards or glaring issues, it has a good chance of passing the appraisal.

If you opt for a VA loan, it’s critical that you work with both a real estate agent and a lender that have a record of working with VA borrowers. They will help you navigate the VA property guidelines, and a good real estate agent can help you craft a winning offer with a VA loan.

Related reading: How to Get a VA Offer Accepted: 7 Tips to Stand Out in a Hot Market

Some sellers prefer offers with Conventional loans because they assume the sale is more likely to go off without a hitch. They worry that accepting a VA offer means they’ll need to make costly repairs or settle for a lower sale price. 

But that’s not necessarily true.

Loan limits

VA borrowers who have full entitlement do not have loan limits. But those who have partial entitlement will be subject to loan limits, just as Conventional conforming borrowers are.

The 2024 loan limits for conforming loans and VA loans with less than full entitlement are the same:

‍Loan limits can change annually. The figures in this table were accurate at the time they were published.

Loan limits are based on local housing prices, so they vary based on where you live and the type of home you’re buying.

Conventional private mortgage insurance vs VA loan funding fee

Conventional loans require private mortgage insurance (PMI) when borrowers put down less than 20%. PMI rates are usually 0.5-1.5% of the loan amount, though your rate will depend on your credit score, down payment, and other factors.

Once you have reached 20% equity in your home, you can request that the PMI be removed.

VA loans do not have a monthly private mortgage requirement, but they do have an upfront funding fee.

The funding fee amount depends on your down payment amount and whether you’re using your VA home loan benefit for the first time or for subsequent purchases.

VA FUNDING FEES FOR FIRST-TIME BORROWERS

VA FUNDING FEES FOR SUBSEQUENT HOME LOANS

VA borrowers who have a service-related disability may be exempt from the funding fee.

VA vs. Conventional loan mortgage rates

Mortgage rates fluctuate often, and the rate you’ll receive depends on your credit score, down payment, loan amount, and where you’re buying.

However, generally comparing the rates between VA loans and Conventional loans, VA loanshave had the lowest rates in the market for the past several years, even more so than the other government-backed loan programs (USDA and FHA loans).

Still, borrowers with high credit scores and solid finances can qualify for competitive Conventional loan interest rates as well.

Your best bet is to request quotes from several lenders so you can compare the costs on different loan programs from different companies and choose the all-around best fit.

VA loan vs. Conventional loan FAQs

Is a VA loan better than a conventional loan? A VA loan is one of the best mortgage options in the market — if you’re eligible, that is. Only veterans, active-duty servicemembers, and some surviving spouses can qualify for these zero down loans.

VA loans don’t require mortgage insurance, and borrowers with full entitlement don’t have loan limits, either. They can also be more affordable for homebuyers with lower credit scores, as Conventional loan interest rates can be higher for borrowers with credit scores under 680.

However, Conventional loans offer a lot of benefits as well. The minimum down payment is just 3%, and the private mortgage insurance (PMI) requirement ends when you reach 20% home equity. If you put down 20% on a Conventional loan, you don’t have to pay PMI at all.

In the current housing market, some sellers prefer offers with Conventional loans to those with VA financing.

What are the disadvantages of a VA loan? VA loans have strict property requirements that can make for a tough appraisal process, especially if the home is older and hasn’t been well-maintained. You can only use a VA loan to buy a primary residence, whereas Conventional loans may be used to finance vacation homes and investment properties.  

Why are VA home loans bad? VA home loans aren’t bad at all. For eligible borrowers, they’re a path to homeownership with zero money down and a competitive interest rate.

But VA loans suffer from a misconception that they’re much harder to close, from a seller’s perspective.

The VA’s minimum property requirements are stricter than those for other loan types, and if an appraiser sees an issue, it must be repaired before the loan can be approved. Lenders cannot approve VA loans for more than the fair market value of the home, so if the appraisal comes in low, the seller may have to reduce the sale price in order to close.

However, many VA borrowers are highly qualified homebuyers, and a property that’s in good, move-in ready condition and has been priced appropriately has a good chance of passing the appraisal.

VA vs. Conventional loans: How do I choose?

Deciding whether to go with a VA or Conventional loan comes down to your financial situation and goals.

If you qualify for a VA loan and you’re buying a home that will be your primary residence, VA loans are hard to beat. No down payment, no loan limits, no private mortgage insurance, and a chance at low interest rates — that’s tough to turn down.

However, Conventional loans are the leading loan type for a reason. They’re attractive to sellers, the property requirements are less strict, and you can use them to buy a vacation home or investment property.

The good news is, you don’t have to decide which type of loan to use on your own. When you apply for pre-approval†††, your lender will tell you the programs you’re eligible for and can explain the pros and cons of each.

They can also give you an estimate of your loan costs for both a VA and Conventional mortgage so you can go over the numbers and figure out which one best aligns with your budget and home-buying goals.

_{†A down payment is required if the borrower does not have full VA entitlement or when the loan amount exceeds the VA county limits. VA loans subject to individual VA Entitlement amounts and eligibility, qualifying factors such as income and credit guidelines, and property limits. Fairway is not affiliated with any government agencies. These materials are not from VA, HUD or FHA, and were not approved by VA, HUD or FHA, USDA or RD, or any other government agency. ††Eligibility subject to program stipulations, qualifying factors, applicable income and debt-to-income (DTI) restrictions, and property limits. †††Pre-approval is based on a preliminary review of credit information provided to Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation, which has not been reviewed by underwriting. If you have submitted verifying documentation, you have done so voluntarily. Final loan approval is subject to a full underwriting review of support documentation including, but not limited to, applicants’ creditworthiness, assets, income information, and a satisfactory appraisal. Some references sourced within this article have not been prepared by Fairway and are distributed for educational purposes only. The information is not guaranteed to be accurate and may not entirely represent the opinions of Fairway. Copyright©2024 Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation. NMLS#2289. 4750 S. Biltmore Lane, Madison, WI 53718, 1-866-912-4800. Fairway is not affiliated with any government agencies. All rights reserved. This is not an offer to enter into an agreement. Not all customers will qualify. Information, rates and programs are subject to change without notice. All products are subject to credit and property approval. Other restrictions and limitations may apply. Equal Housing Opportunity.}